????????棰?锛?璇鸿?灏?缁?娴?瀛兀?锛?浠???璁虹??绌惰蛋??瀹?璇???绌?/P>

??????瑕?

?????寸淮路?″痉??璐＄???涓昏????ㄧ?楠???绌舵?规?瀵瑰?冲?ㄧ?娴?瀛﨎???????涓?浜???澶ч???杩?琛?浜?妫?楠?锛?浠???涓哄???ョ????绌舵??绔?浜?姒??枫??

?????ㄥ?????ㄦ??伐?疯?寮??ュ??浼????扮?娴?瀛﨎?????杩?绋?涓??瀹??奸?????瑰???????????ヤ?宸ㄥぇ??浣??ㄣ??瀹??奸?????圭??宸ヤ?涓昏?????宸叉?????规?搴??ㄥ?颁?澶ч??瀹??????????绌朵腑锛???渚?浜?浣跨?ㄨ??渚?????????????绌朵富瑕??????稿?崇???规?杩?琛?浜??ㄥ箍???硅?锛?浠???璁╁?浠??村?????ㄤ?瀹?璺靛??ㄣ??

????涓?涔???锛?2021骞磋?璐?灏?缁?娴?瀛兀?????锛?杩?娆＄??寰?涓绘?诲?辨??涓?浣?锛?????????宸?澶у?浼????╁???＄???????寸淮路?″痉锛?David Card锛???楹荤????宸ュ??㈢??????涔???浜?路D路瀹??奸?????癸?Joshua D. Angrist锛?浠ュ?????�>?澶у?????????澶?路W路???????Guido W. Imbens锛????朵腑锛??″痉???峰?????瀵瑰?冲?ㄧ?娴?瀛兀?璇???绌舵?х??璐＄???????峰?璇ュ???涓???锛???瀹??奸?????瑰??????????????瀵瑰?????崇郴???????规?瀛嗀础???????卞????浜??�????濂?椤广??

????涓????″痉???冲?ㄧ?娴?瀛嗀础????ㄧ?楠???绌舵?规?瀵归???杩?琛?妫?楠?

????浣?涓轰????冲?ㄧ?娴?瀛兀?锛??″痉????绌惰???村?烘?????浜?杩?涓???????ㄩ?ㄩ??瑕?璁????瀹?浜?姹????拌?锛?濡???浠?寮????х??瑙?搴�>??锛??″痉骞朵?绠?绐??猴???涓轰?????绌剁??璁???跺???浜哄??涔??藉凡缁?娑???杩???浠?涓?汉瀵逛?杩?涓??绉???璐＄???涓昏????ㄧ?楠???绌舵?规?瀵瑰?冲?ㄧ?娴?瀛﨎???????涓?浜???澶ч???杩?琛?浜?妫?楠?锛?浠???涓哄???ョ????绌舵??绔?浜?姒??枫??

?????ㄥ?″痉??浼?澶???绌朵腑锛?????????涓?涓??????宸叉????缁?娴?瀛兀??句鸡路??椴??硷?Alan Krueger锛???杩?琛????充???浣?宸ヨ????????绌躲???挎??浠ユ?ワ?缁?娴?瀛�>??涓??村???浣?宸ヨ?????搴?浜?璁轰?浼???涓?绉?瑙??硅?涓猴???浣?宸ヨ????ㄨ???互涓哄?冲?ㄨ????渚??村ソ??淇???锛????�??绉?瑙??瑰??璁や负锛???浣?宸ヨ????ㄨ??????浣?浼?涓???浣ｅ?冲?ㄥ???????匡?浠????????村???澶变???灏界?杩?涓ょ?瑙??归?藉??????????锛?浣??讳??ヨ?锛???涓?绉?瑙??瑰??颁??村?缁?娴?瀛兀???????锛?????????剁??涓绘?瑙??广??

?????ｄ?锛?杩?绉?瑙??圭┒绔???????纭???????″痉????椴??艰?涓猴?涓??跺?ㄧ??璁轰?浜?璁轰?浼?锛?涓?濡??ㄦ?版???瀵??板?涓??????靛?板?????涔??风????涓?杩?锛?瑕?浠?缁?楠?涓???瀵?杩?涓????锛?骞朵????ｄ?瀹规??????浠???璁轰???锛?瑕???涓?涓??跨???????濡?浣?锛?灏遍??瑕?姣?杈??跨?瀹??藉?????舵??锛?浠ュ???ㄦ病???跨?瀹??界??????浜?瀹????舵??涔??寸??宸?????浣????涓?涓??跨???涔????芥?㈠??藉??娌℃??瀹??藉????ㄤ袱?惧?骞村??锛????卞????棰???????绌惰???剧????鸿?涓?涓?В?虫?规?锛?瀹?灏辨????璋???????宸??????????宸??????甯告???轰??????跺?楠???锛?涓????ㄦ??绉?澶????跨??插?荤???烘??腑杩?琛???瀹?涓昏???瀵?????袱缁?瑙?瀵?瀵硅薄锛?涓?缁??????扳?????跺?楠???骞查?????骞查?缁???锛??�??缁?????病?????扳?????跺?楠???骞查?????瀵圭?х??????ㄥ共棰???????锛?涓や釜缁???骞冲??琛ㄧ?板??ㄧ??涓?瀹???宸???????ㄥ共棰???????锛?杩?涓?樊??????灏?浼???????????杩??讹?杩?涓???宸???宸???灏卞??互琚??涓烘??共棰???寮?????褰卞????

?????″痉????椴??煎?骞歌??版?惧?颁?杩??蜂?涓??????跺?楠?????涓?涓?绾?0浠ｅ??锛?缇??芥?版辰瑗垮?????浣?灏??跺伐璧?浠?4.25缇?????楂???.05缇???锛?浣?涓?姝ゅ???跺???版辰瑗垮?姣??荤??瀹惧?娉?灏间?宸???娌℃??杩?琛?璋??淬??杩??讹???浣??跨????哄?板氨??浜?涓?涓???澶?????骞查???锛???涓や釜宸???浼?涓?灏卞????舰??浜?涓?涓???骞查?缁?????涓?涓???瀵圭?х??????″痉????椴??煎????????浜?涓や釜宸?蹇??搴???宸ヨ???灏变??版?????杩???绌跺???帮???浣?宸ヨ??跨????哄?板苟娌℃????褰??剁??涓绘?瑙??规??棰?璁＄???ｆ?凤?澧????版辰瑗垮???澶变?????寰??剧?讹??㈠?杩??风??缁?楠?缁???锛?缁?娴?瀛兀?浠?氨涓?寰?涓?瀵逛?缁???璁洪???拌?琛?瀹¤???

?????″痉???�??椤归??瑕???绌舵???充?绉绘??????ㄥ??剁??缇??戒??存??涓?涓??琛???瑙??癸??崇Щ姘???澧???浼??ゅ?????板?姘?锛?灏ゅ?舵???浣????叉按骞冲?姘???灏变???????锛?寰?澶??版?规?垮??藉?哄?颁????剁Щ姘????稿?虫???姐??杩?涓??琛???瑙??圭┒绔???????纭??????涓轰?瀵瑰?惰?琛?楠?璇?锛??″痉??涓?娆＄キ?轰?????宸??????

????1980骞???锛??ゅ反???℃???圭??垮???????澶??版?惧?ㄤ?绉绘??跨?锛???璁告???藉?姘????辩Щ姘?娴峰????ㄨ?涓??跨???????锛???澶ч???ゅ反灞?姘?绉诲??颁?缇??姐??浠?浠?1980骞???????杩?????涓????堕?达?绉绘?缇??界???ゅ反浜哄氨杈惧?颁?12涓?5??浜恒???变??扮?????朵?涓?浜???绱?锛?缇??借??垮?甯???涓轰??????ゅ反绉绘?????????甯?锛?绉绘?涓???澶ч?ㄥ??浜洪?介???╀??ㄦ?瀹?灞???????澶ч??绉绘???娑??ワ?杩??垮?甯????冲?ㄥ??渚?缁?澶у?锛????搁?荤???朵???甯???????涓?澶с??杩??讹?杩??垮?灏辨??浜?涓?涓???骞查?缁???锛????朵???甯?????互褰㈡??涓?涓???瀵圭?х??????″痉??杩?????宸????锛????板?ㄧЩ姘?澶ч??娑??ュ????锛?杩??垮????板?姘???澶变???骞舵病??姣??搁?诲??甯????捐????澧?????寰??剧?讹?杩?涔?璇存??浜?缁?娴?瀛�?腑?充?绉绘?????浼?缁??烘?р??骞朵????涔?姝ｇ‘??

????杩?????瑕?璇存????????变??″痉??涓???绌剁??缁?璁洪?藉??浼?缁???缁?娴???璁烘??涓?瀹??哄?ワ?骞朵?杩?浜?缁?璁洪?芥?板ソ绗兀???板?ㄦ??璋??????挎不姝ｇ‘??????蹇碉???姝ゅ?ㄤ??峰?璇鸿?灏?缁?娴?瀛兀???娑?????哄??锛?涓?灏?浜鸿?涓烘???轰?涓?绉??挎不???????ㄧ??????ワ?瀵规?锛???浠??璇ョ???у?扮??寰???璇?濂?涓????芥??涓?浜??稿?崇??????锛?浣?浜?瀹?涓?锛??″痉??汉瀵逛?瀛�=???稿?涓ヨ皑锛??充娇浠?????绌剁?璁烘????互浜?璁轰?澶?锛?浣??冲?浠?????绌剁???规?????搴�=???煎?瀛�??????

????浜???瀹??奸?????广???????????????ㄦ??/STRONG>

?????规???璐?灏?濂?璇?瀹″???浼???澹版??锛?瀹??奸?????瑰?????????浜烘???变??ㄥ?????ㄦ???归?㈢??宸ヤ?????浜???兀???涓??璐?灏?濂???????璋??????ㄦ???????绌跺?浣??╃?ㄩ?????哄?楠??版??????涔??寸???????崇郴杩?琛?璇?????涓??ㄥ????????涓?涓?绾?0骞翠唬锛??板?瀹堕?瀹炬???轰??????ㄦ????????妗??朵???锛?杩?涓??规?灏辫???琚??娴?瀛�>?????ュ??锛?浠?????涓轰?璁￠??缁?娴?瀛兀?浠???甯哥?ㄧ??宸ュ?枫??
?????ㄨ?椤瑰伐?疯?寮??ュ??浼????扮?娴?瀛﨎?????杩?绋?涓??瀹??奸?????瑰?????????藉???ヤ?宸ㄥぇ??浣??ㄣ??涓?杩?锛?浠?璐＄?????归?㈢??锛?杩?涓や汉涔??存????ㄧ??宸ㄥぇ??宸??????瀹??奸?????圭??宸ヤ?涓昏?????宸叉?????规?搴??ㄥ?颁?澶ч??瀹??????????绌跺?涓??浠???涓轰娇?ㄨ?浜??规???渚?浜???渚????ゆ?涔?澶?锛?浠?杩?缂???浜?涓ゆ???充??????ㄦ??????绉?涔�
??????澶?璇讳功?板???互甯�=?ュ?澶х?????ワ???杩??????茬?娴?瀛﨎???????甯歌???涓?涓????????璁告??浜鸿?涓猴?杩?涓????涓??惧??绛?锛???涓????????插勾????浜虹???跺?ヨ?琛?姣?杈?灏卞??互浜???浣?????剧?舵病??杩?涔?绠?????涓?涓?汉?ュ??澶?灏????诧???寰?澶???绱???褰卞????姣?濡?锛?涓?涓?汉瀹跺?濂斤?浠??????茬???堕?村氨澶???浣?涓?姝ゅ???讹?浠??充娇涓??????诧?涔??借?峰?楂??跺?ャ???ㄨ?绉????典?锛???浠??充娇???颁????版?村????茬??浜虹???跺?ユ?撮?锛?涔????借??????插勾?????跺?ヤ??存???稿?冲?崇郴锛???涓??界‘瀹?涓よ?????兀??ㄥ?????崇郴??
?????ｄ?锛???涔????借????????崇郴???杩??????抽??氨????惧?颁?涓???璋?????宸ュ?峰??????锛?璁╁???奖?????插勾??锛???涓?浼???杩??朵?娓????存?ュ奖???跺?ャ??濡?????杩??蜂?涓?????锛??ｄ???浠?氨??互??杩?瀹?涓????插勾?????跺?ヤ??寸???崇郴锛??存?ュ?版?ㄦ???烘???插勾??瀵规?跺?ュ奖??????????搴???
??????????浠?涔??风????????绗兀??瑕?姹????瀹??奸?????规?惧?扮????????汉?????ャ???规????界??涔??℃???叉?锛?????骞存弧6?ㄥ???瀛﨎??跨?锛??藉?椤诲?ㄨ?骞寸??9??浠藉?ュ??ュ?????层??骞朵?????褰?骞存弧16宀????跺??锛?瀛�>????琚???璁歌?瀛�:??
???????ц?涓??瀹?锛?涓?涓?汉濡????虹??????浠芥?╋??ｄ?浠??ㄥ?ュ????跺??锛?骞冲??骞撮?灏变?姣?杈?澶э???濡???浠??虹??????浠芥?杈???锛????ュ??剁??骞冲??骞撮?灏变?姣?杈?灏????蜂??ヨ?锛?濡???瀛╁??虹???ㄧ?涓?瀛ｅ害锛??ｄ?浠??ㄤ?瀛�>???跺??骞冲??宀??板ぇ绾�=??.45宀?锛???濡???瀛╁??虹???ㄧ???瀛ｅ害锛?浠?浠??ュ??剁??骞冲??骞撮???????6.07宀????变?涓????虹???堕?寸??浜猴??ュ??跺????骞撮????????锛?浣????浠????璁歌?瀛�>??骞撮??存???稿????锛???姝ゅ钩???ヨ?锛??虹????浠借?????浜烘?ュ???????插勾??灏辫??裤????绔???锛?濡????插?虹??????1?ワ???涔??虹????2??31?ワ?骞朵?涓や汉?介???╄?瀛�
??????杩?绠?????楠?璇?锛???浠?氨??互?ラ???虹???堕?寸‘瀹?绗兀??浣?涓哄伐?峰??????瑕?姹?????瀹??剧?朵?褰卞???????插勾??锛?浣?涓?姝ゅ???跺?翠?浼??存?ュ奖???跺?ャ???╃?ㄥ?浣?涓哄伐?峰????锛?瀹??奸?????瑰????椴??煎???帮?棰?澶?1骞寸??涔??℃???插?浼?璁╀汉???跺?ュ???9%???㈣?涔?锛?澶??ュ??涓?骞存???插???诲伐浣?锛??跺?????绠?????
????浠?姝ゆ?璇鸿?灏?缁?娴?瀛�>???峰?????互???猴?璇鸿?灏?缁?娴?瀛兀?璇?濂?寮?濮?浠???璁虹??绌舵?村??板??瀹?璇???绌惰浆绉伙??村???虫敞?板??????姝ゅ?锛?瓒??ヨ?澶???缁?娴?瀛�>?????绌堕?????瀛嗀??灏????借?峰?杩?涓?濂?椤癸?????井瑙?缁?娴?瀛�:??????缁?娴?瀛�:??璁￠??缁?娴?瀛�:??琛?涓虹?娴?瀛�:?????告不??????灞?缁?娴?瀛�>???
????锛???姘镐?锛?浣???绯汇??姣?杈?????绌堕?ㄤ富绠★?